Is My Quote Fair?
Got a quote from a contractor and not sure if it’s fair? Pick your project, answer a few questions about your home, and enter the price you were quoted. We’ll compare it with the typical range for the same job in your area and tell you what to ask before you sign.
Estimated roof replacement cost
$12,400 – $20,200
Typical: $16,300
Quick estimate from 4 answers. Answer the rest for an exact price.
Using national average prices. Add your zip code for local prices.
Sorry, we couldn't calculate that. Please check your answers, or reload the page.
A few more details for accurate quotes
1 roofing square = 100 sq ft. A 20-square roof is 2,000 sq ft.
Typical suburban roof
Codes don't allow a new roof over two existing layers.
Compare quotes from local roofers
Free, with no obligation. Local, pre-screened pros will contact you to confirm your project and give you a price.
Thanks! Your request is in. Local pros will contact you shortly, usually within a business day, to talk about your project.
Check your quote
We compare it with the estimate for your answers and your zip code.
Estimates are a guide. Prices vary with your home and local conditions.
Got more than one quote? Compare them side by side →
Questions to ask
Red flags
How the quote checker works
- We price your job. Your answers go through the same calculator and formula as the rest of the site, adjusted for your region by your zip code.
- We compare your quote. You’ll see whether it’s well below, below, within, above or well above the typical range, and where it sits on a low-to-high bar.
- You get questions to ask. Each project has its own list of questions, and if a quote looks high, the red flags worth checking.
Nothing is sent anywhere when you check a quote. The comparison happens in your browser.
What the result means
| Result | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Well below | Under three quarters of our low figure | Check what’s left out (permits, disposal, product grade) and get it in writing |
| Below typical | Under our low figure | Can be a good deal; make sure it’s itemized and complete |
| Within range | Between our low and high figures | Normal for your area; compare what each quote includes |
| Above typical | Up to 30% over our high figure | Ask what’s driving the price; get a second quote |
| Well above | More than 30% over our high figure | Get at least two more quotes before signing |
A quote outside our range isn’t proof that it’s wrong. Your home may need things a calculator can’t see. Use the result to ask better questions, not to accuse anyone of overcharging.
Help us improve our prices
After checking, you can add your quote anonymously to ImprovementCalc’s price data. It’s optional and off unless you tick the box. We store the price, your answers and the first three digits of your zip code, never your name, contact details or full zip code. Once a project has enough reports, its calculator shows what other homeowners were quoted. You can also share what your project cost once it’s finished.
Read how we estimate costs for the full method, and our privacy policy for how price reports are handled.